Conscious Selection

Chapter 11. Fifty-Two Cycles

Conscious Selection7 min

11

Fifty-Two Cycles

The requirement with which the last chapter ended sounds noble and means nothing until it turns into a procedure.

Lying to oneself being technically inconvenient: if you translate that from the noble into engineering, how does it work?


It is arranged insultingly simply, and of course I was not the one who thought it up.

Before measuring anything, I write down in a separate file what exactly I expect to see: what quantity, in which direction, what size of effect and at which outcome I am obliged to admit I was wrong. The file goes into the code repository, after which a fingerprint is taken of it, a short string that changes completely if you correct so much as a comma in the file, and this fingerprint is entered into a common register with today’s date.

Only after that is the measurement run.

Cheating, of course, has not gone anywhere: I can still rewrite a prediction after the fact, but then the fingerprint will stop matching, and anyone who opens the register will see it. The garden of forking paths, in which I had such a nice stroll in the last chapter, is closed off here purely mechanically: a single path remains, and it is written down in advance.

Over a few years nine rules have grown up around this procedure, of which I will name three. Read the literature before registering the prediction, not after. Do not count fewer than a thousand independent runs as a result. And as a separate item, hard-won from my own mistakes, there is a check for tautology: whether what I am going to measure might turn out to be a simple consequence of how I defined it.

As of today there are fifty-two predictions in the register.

After purchase

This chapter is part of the full edition

The opening chapters are free. The full book is available after purchase and stays in your library.

· · Already bought it? Sign in

An email when new chapters and experiments come out

At most once a week. No account needed; unsubscribe in one click.